The shoes I received were clearly worn previously, or at least one of them was. One has stains on the side and is quite stretched. The two shoes are different sizes and so I can't rate size accuracy; see photo. Both are marked 8m. One felt more like a 9-9 1/2 and the other like a large 8-8 1/2. The smaller of the two was slightly wide (with thin socks) and definitely too long in the toe. I wear a 38EU or an 8mUS always, unless a company clearly states a size variation.I like the look very much, and if they were the correct size would be exactly what I'm looking for. The leather isn't the highest quality so don't expect to compare them to a high-end brand.I am of course returning this "pair" and am debating an exchange. Size 7m is currently $25 more than the size 8m.The first photo is to show the different sizes and the second shows the stains on one shoe.I will update this review if I purchase again in another size.