I like these flats but they came pretty tight on the left foot. the toe shape was not exactly symmetrical either, the right looks rounder and the left a little square. I had to take a hammer to them to loosen up the left foot behind the heal and over the top of the left toe but they are leather so I was able to remedy the tightness that way and they are pretty comfortable now. I wish they were a little lighter brown though, more honey than reddish. Seems like they are pretty sturdy and will last a while but I've only worn them a few weeks now.